"The Scarlet Letter," the greatest American novel--Ayn Rand

Posted by WDonway 11 years, 6 months ago to Books
5 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

I study examples of Romantic Art for my Facebook page, "Romantic Revolution Books." Ayn Rand called Nathaniel Hawthorne's most celebrated novel, "The Scarlet Letter," the greatest in American literature. This is entirely consistent with Ayn Rand's commitment to the Romantic school of literature. Hawthorne published "The Scarlet Letter" in 1850, considered the very last year of the Romantic Movement as defined by historians (although four out of five of Victor Hugo's novels were published still later).

Notice, immediately, that "The Scarlet Letter" is about an immensely strong heroine, Hester Prynne, who is loved by two men with sharply conflicting values--this is almost an Ayn Rand signature. On a deeper level, this is a novel about the conflict of values that go to the soul of the characters. The story is set in New England in the years 1642-1649, the very height of the Puritan ascendancy. Hester will not accept guilt for an action deemed pure sin and transgression by her society; which demand she identify on her breast that she is an adulterer, and thus she sews a beautiful, elaborate, defiant scarlet "A." Her love, Aurther Dimmesdale, minster of the village, will not do the same; and nothing will make Hester give him away. She is one of the great, defiant heroines of American literature.

Her husband, long thought lost at sea, appears in the crowd at her public humiliation for her "sin." He seeks revenge in the name of "sin" and "transgression," whereas Hester protects her lover in the name of love according to her own values. At every point, we are presented with the conflict between conventional morality, backed by all the authority of public disapproval, and the values that actually move Hester and her lover to action. Hester's great spirit survives it all. Hawthorne was writing this almost 200 years after the setting of its story, but at the time "The Scarlet Letter" STILL was a scandal...

I would be interested in hearing how readers reacted to this novel. I think that I was required to read it in Seventh or Eighth Grade, and it made little impression on me.


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
  • Posted by C_S 11 years, 6 months ago
    "The Scarlet Letter" was a very thoughtful and well-written novel. In other words, Ayn Rand learned nothing from it.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Mark 11 years, 6 months ago
    Excellent parallels. I'm always thrilled to see these. Jeff Britting points out that Ayn Rand used to gaze at Salvador Dali's Corpus Hypercubus, a painting of the crucifixion of Jesus. She said it reminded her of John Galt. I am intrigued by Rand's simultaneous animosity toward Christianity and her prevalent use of Christian symbolism. Any thoughts?
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by 11 years, 6 months ago
      Well, Ayn Rand said, I think, that this was her favorite painting. It is in what she called the "conceptual style," achieving a hyper-clarity beyond realism. The painting by Dali in 1954, re-titled, "The Crucifixion," when it was acquired by the Metropolitan Museum of Art, was one Ayn Rand is said to have stood contemplating for hours. She said, I believe, that the beautiful male figure reminded her of John Galt, and made the point, often made, that this Christ has no wounds, no blood; his crucifixion, his torture, is spiritual, of the soul. Even more, I think, she may have been attracted to the figure of Mary Magdalene, kneeling before the cross, in a posture of reverence to the ideal man, the hero. Ayn Rand conceived of the proper relationship between man and woman, in the romantic-sexual context only, as the woman's hero worship of the man--her response to his creative strength. Naturally, a woman can have the same creative strength as a man, be as heroic, but in the romantic-sexual context the role of her strength is to respond to the very highest in a man and to reward it by surrendering herself, making an exception for a hero. Or so, I gather, was Ayn Rand's position on this.

      As for Ayn Rand's use of Christian symbolism, well, we have to keep in mind she was a Nineteenth Century Russian philosopher (and novelist). She certainly was not unaware of the role of the Church as the only defender of the intellect and scholarship through the centuries of the Dark Ages and early Middle Ages. And, of course, that the greatest Western philosopher after Aristotle was Thomas Aquinas, the transmission belt for Aristotle into Europe in modern times.

      But more than that, I think, anyone brought up on the Christian tradition as a child has to retain a powerful feeling associating Jesus with goodness and moral perfection and consummate moral courage... Almost all of the great inspirational symbols in our culture derive from or are associated with Christianity: light, rising, the march forward of the right, vengeance against evil, deliverance, the sky, the child, redemption, innocent nudity, sunrise, mountains and high places...it just goes on and on. A novelist who wishes to tune into our deepest implicit feelings hardly can avoid a great deal of Christian symbolism. Having said all this, I have made no special study of Christian symbolism in Ayn Rand's novels. She also is notable for creating a great many symbols, a great deal of imagery of inspiration, that begins to give us alternatives to Christian symbols.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
      • Posted by C_S 11 years, 6 months ago
        "But more than that, I think, anyone brought up on the Christian tradition as a child"

        That leaves Rand out.

        "A novelist who wishes to tune into our deepest implicit feelings hardly can avoid a great deal of Christian symbolism."

        Rather, because Christians claim Christianity is the embodiment of all good, they will lay claim to anyone else's use of the good, even in a completely non-Christian context, as "actually" being innately Christian.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Comment hidden by post owner or admin, or due to low comment or member score. View Comment
      • Posted by C_S 11 years, 6 months ago
        "She certainly was not unaware of the role of the Church as the only defender of the intellect and scholarship through the centuries of the Dark Ages and early Middle Ages."

        Wow. Talk about benighted.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo