yes and the consensus as far as I know was a resounding NO. he is a bump on a log. so a tree trunk must now be the see in from of the desk used by the president.

Not really, since the previous topic used the word "Dedicated Member" in the question. This question implied simply a resident, not a Dedicated member of the Gulch.

Much like a question does a person have to be Jewish to live in Jerusalem or Israel?

Phraseology is very important.

Actually, "To each according to their needs, from each according to their ability" is just a motto. Osama's and the despots before him. In reality, it is "steal as much as you can from as many as you can." And that suits a lot of people quite well...

Well if you really ARE a Timelord, that is a very big possibility! Quite appropriate.

It depends on what you mean by Christianity. If it's the real one as preached and practiced through the dark and middle ages, and sometimes in that form still today, than yes, it's just as bad. But if it's modern 'Christian' culture thoroughly watered down by the secularism since the Enlightenment and formed by and practiced as in fact American individualism it's possible to see how someone could be confused and still actually endorse the values of the Gulch if he doesn't actually take Christian mysticism and duty seriously, It's not Ayn Rand's philosophy because it corrupts it and contradicts it at the root, but it can be more civilization and individualism than most of what else is going on today. Honesty will sort it out one way or the other as an individual learns.

But for Obama, there is only one version: him. If you know what he's doing and saying you can't confuse it with the Gulch.

Being entitled to your own views doesn't make them right. The question was about the content of one's position, not the biological possibility of endorsing falsehood and contradiction.