Gluten Free?
Yes, this is relevant!
I'm reading "Grain Brain: The Surprising Truth about Wheat, Carbs, and Sugar--Your Brain's Silent Killers" by David Perlmutter. I don't really care to dive into big pharma, food industry, FDA, or government conspiracy here - I'm just interested in the science and how it pertains to brain function (naturally, my own, and people I care about).
Has anyone here tried a gluten free, low carb diet and noticed significant differences in mental acuity, stress, and/or any chronic illness?
I'm starting such a diet this week, and I'll report on my experience if there's interest.
I'm reading "Grain Brain: The Surprising Truth about Wheat, Carbs, and Sugar--Your Brain's Silent Killers" by David Perlmutter. I don't really care to dive into big pharma, food industry, FDA, or government conspiracy here - I'm just interested in the science and how it pertains to brain function (naturally, my own, and people I care about).
Has anyone here tried a gluten free, low carb diet and noticed significant differences in mental acuity, stress, and/or any chronic illness?
I'm starting such a diet this week, and I'll report on my experience if there's interest.
Was I "smarter"? Maybe not...since I had to restock my closet.
FYI: Our pets (cat/dog) also went on a grain-free diet. HUGE improvement and elimination of maladies!!
I'm curious about what you mean by "mild stuffiness". Is that something like "foggy brain"? I get a sensation of head congestion or stuffiness or fogginess fairly regularly, and it tends to result in anxiety. i.e. "Oh no! What's going on with my brain. Is it going to stop working? Am I about to drop over dead?"
go comment on my controversial post
Harder than ever to be gluten free unless you eat MEAT and POTATOES - which, believe it or not, is what my family always said was their staple diet on the farm.
Turns out that cholesterol is vital to brain function and the cell membranes of every cell in your body - we need it in abundance, and every cell in your body can actually manufacture its own supply. The true danger seems to come from the oxidation of LDL and HDL (cholesterol containers) which can be prevented by MORE fat consumption and antioxidants.
Low fat, high carb diets appear to be the real cause behind the surge in diabetes and chronic health issues. Don't tell the drug companies. (Ack, I said I wouldn't go there)
Have a good friend who suffered from lots of muscle and joint pain, IBS. 6 Months on gluten free and years of chronic pains went away. was not overnight. If her mental acuity sharpened after the new diet, I do not think she would have said...because there were all those arguments she had with us BEFORE the diet changes she still would have claimed superior mental acuity. what can you do? (Gallic shrug)
(Glad to hear your friend is better!)
.
Recommend the podcasts by Jimmy Moore (ask the low carb experts), as well as the documentary 'Fathead' (available on netflix streaming when I saw it)
Consumers want low price food, and wheat is the cheapest starch source. But wheat gluten has big advantages for baked foods, it adds moist texture, which again the consumer wants.
Its worth the small effort, but don't waste money on special "gluten free" substitutes. Just build habits of naturally GF food like potatoes or rice.
In the first month, be very strict. If you accidentally eat gluten you have to start the day-count again. If you have an intolerance, you will notice the improvement not before about 3 weeks. Thats how long the intestine lining needs to repair.
Good luck!
Other people's results from dietary changes are their results. They may not be your results; they may not even be close...
Some folks do well on that screwy all meat diet... I worked with a guy who tried it. I never say a man eat so much wonderful meat and look so utterly malnourished! There is little I love more than a 32oz dry-aged Porterhouse, but I've gotta have potatoes & bread to go with it!
My advice to anyone trying to gain control of their 'diet' -- KNOCK OFF the DIET SODA -- No one, not one single person *NEEDS* artificially sweetened beverages, foods, snacks, etc... STOP RATIONALIZING. If you're thirsty drink WATER -- good'old dihydrogen monoxide ;)
Folks that want to change their brain by changing their diet have it all bass-ackwards; change your mind and you will alter your physiology! Eat healthy, eat luxuriously, eat sparingly, eat when you are hungry. Try not to eat when you are *BORED*, if you want to skip a meal then skip it, but don't skip a meal to earn praise; it's an empty reward.
Fix your diet in the *SUPERMARKET* -- don't buy what you don't need, don't but what you know will cause you to over-indulge (that's also the best way to quit smoking -- don't buy tobacco, you won't smoke what you don't have).
Visit there and check out the Learn More button for more details.
The first time I tried to go low carb (which unfortunately includes both potatoes and rice), I hit a wall and bounced: I was unable to rid myself of morning-mind-fog. So I modified my diet and had simple carbs for breakfast, but not otherwise. Then - a couple of years later - I tried again...and this time, I did not hit the wall; there was no problem with giving up my morning simple carbs. (Evidently, my body had acclimated.) This stopped my weight gain (~1-2 lb/yr), but I did not loose any weight.
Then I read Wheat Belly and (in spite of several logical flaws in the book) decided to try it as an experiment. I removed all gluten from my diet. I began loosing weight at the rate of about a pound a week* for a while and my occasional digestive problems went away. I am now on the Tim Ferris version of the low-carb diet (which cycles back onto carbs/gluten once a week) and I have started loosing weight again.
As long as I follow the 'do no harm' principle, I am in favor of experimenting with mine own body, and I regard this as a successful experiment.
Jan
*Interestingly enough this was halted by a sting or bite on my arm (arm was pretty swollen) - did not loose any more weight after that happened.
The sting sounds odd... did you get checked for Lyme Disease after that?
Long story short she was diagnosed with Celiac disease and we took our whole family Gluten Free. I have benefitted greatly from this change so I'm sure I have it to. Most of my benefits come in the form of less stomach troubles.
We are different then lots of people I meet who are Gluten Free in that we aren't concerned with super healthy stuff, just Gluten Free of the same things. But overall we probably eat healthier then we otherwise would.
Let me know if you have any Gluten Free questions.
I was looking into decent gluten free beers (it looks like there are some), but my short term solution is switching to wine (Chardonnays mostly). I was wondering about teas this morning. I'm drinking decaf Lipton with Splenda, and assuming it's gluten free (couldn't find any explicit statement on the Lipton website). I drink decaf Earl Grey tea at home.
The beer is going to be hard to give up *sigh*.
And wine is good ;)
Now, after a year of losing weight and regaining my memory. I feel much better than I have in years. Shedding my 400 pound wife helped as well.
I definitely see gluten, carbs, and sugar as three distinct items to avoid as much as possible. The book's title implies that it's mostly about gluten, but the author is a neurologist, so he's going through it all in terms of how the brain reacts to foods/ingredients. The science is just at the edge of my understanding, but not incomprehensible.
Out of curiosity, what's with the sarcasm?