If there was something you could change about any of the three specific films in the Atlas Shrugged Trilogy, what would it be?
List any changes you would make if you could about one of the three films. Don't talk about the trilogy as a whole, talk about one of the films specifically. You can list problems in each of the films seperately if you want as well.
For me what I would change is the extreme amount of narration in Part III to many talking heads and not enough showing of the world. Too much exposition.
For me what I would change is the extreme amount of narration in Part III to many talking heads and not enough showing of the world. Too much exposition.
This is the result of thinking about it for 5 minutes, so it isn't an exhaustive list.
Lillian's blackmail of Dagny
Dagny's radio speech
Dagny and Hank's meeting afterward
Project X (demo and Stadler takeover attempt, gives a reason for the Taggart Bridge collapse)
Eddie's recognition of Galt's voice at the Thompson speech (needs setup in earlier movies)
In the Gulch, have arrivals be in the same order as the book (prevent timeline confusion)
Francisco's "I don't have to leave" line.
Dagny meets Ragnar at Galt's house, breakfast on June 1st.
The September 2 destruction of d'Anconia Copper (even if as a brief news report)
The "Brother, you asked for it" line, somewhere....
I know this applies to all 3 movies but I'll say it anyways: Invent a time machine, bring a Fantasy Island-era Ricardo Montalban forward in time and cast him as Francisco.
Really...out in the middle of nowhere AND they have cell service? How about the fact that cellphones can be tracked? Did nobody think that the government might be looking for these folks?
Also, the homes were far too well built. This was to be a simple, primitive community, where people built their own places. At least, give them log cabins or places built of stone...those could still be pretty nice.
What I would personally change is have a substoryline of Hank and Lillian Rearden in AS3. I would have loved to see him walk out on her after he lost his company.
I came away from the movie with the sense that the strike had no purpose. A strike is an attempt to show the value of your labor by ceasing activity. Atlas Shrugged 3 left me with the sense that stopping the motor of the world taught nothing. I also left with the sense that Dagny failed in her attempt to save the railroad. The movie felt like it was written by committee, a government bureaucratic collage.
Turn Who is John Galt into a movie not an overplayed cheesy love story. I was so disappointed with part 3 it was an insult to parts 1 & 2.