14

The Forgotten Man: A New History Of The Great Depression

Posted by ObjectiveAnalyst 10 years ago to Books
44 comments | Share | Best of... | Flag

The Forgotten Man: A New History Of The Great Depression

Author, Amity Shlaes History/Economics 420 pages. ISBN 978-0-06-093642-6

Why did a recession and a drop in the stock market snowball out of control and turn into a crash and a depression?
This #1 New York Times Business Bestseller answers these questions. With the benefit of hindsight, this objective retrospective documents in fine detail the mistakes of Hoover and the folly and hubris of FDR and his “brain trust.” It was a most profound period, establishing the progressive, statist government foothold firmly on a path that is still felt today. What should have been just one more typical recession was consequently exacerbated and prolonged, yet the progressives keep offering more of the same.

FDR was a great speaker and cheerleader. His speeches and fireside chats are legendary. He was also a sophist and inept bumbler whose hubris lead him to play arbitrary games with the economy and thus the lives of millions of Americans. Behind the scenes many of his primary “brain trust” advisers and second tier advisers were composed of socialists and communist sympathizers. Many were from the group known as the “Travelers” – a group of naive idealists that were infatuated with the novelty of the USSR after the revolution. They traveled to Russia in order to swoon at the feet of Stalin and Trotsky. Shielded from the atrocities and regaled with the “benefits” of communism they tried to remake America as soon as they could gain the ear of FDR.

Ultimately many of FDR’s policies, persecutions of businessmen and bureaucracies were nullified by the Supreme Court or collapsed under the weight of their own massive failure. Unfortunately, the media, then as today, ignored the actual outcomes in favor of the feel good intentions. That explains the rosy history that has been the predominant view all these years. The details and actual outcomes were ignored, and just in the nick of time war broke out and obscured the policy failures while changing the economic paradigm. Sure, some that fed at the public trough benefited, but overall it was an economic disaster for most. “The Forgotten Man” was the man that suffered in silence, not represented, but footing the bill.

In recent years many of the same misguided policies have been enacted. In retrospect, one day, hopefully soon, more people will see the parallels and we can finally stop repeating the mistakes of the past. The present economics are being covered up and whitewashed with phony accounting methods and disingenuous reporting of actual unemployment figures, etc.

Very well documented with an extensive bibliography anyone reading this book with an ounce of integrity will find it most difficult to perpetuate the mythos of the great FDR.

Definitely a must read for those interested in acquiring an objective perspective and the factual information required to combat the years of propaganda and the non-stop march of statism.

Respectfully,
O.A.


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by straightlinelogic 10 years ago
    OA,
    In the same vein, you might want to check out:
    Rethinking the Great Depression, Gene Smiley,
    America's Great Depression, Murray Rothbard,
    FDR's Folly, Jim Powell
    and my favorite, The Roosevelt Myth, John T. Flynn

    I dug into these, and Ms. Shlaes book, researching my next book. I consider Roosevelt the worst president, and nobody else is close. Anyone who thinks Obama is the worst just doesn't know their presidential history. Thanks for reviewing The Forgotten Man, I thought it was excellent.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by ewv 10 years ago
      Be sure to read the 2nd, updated edition of Flynn's Roosevelt Myth from the 1950s. Flynn was a well-known journalist who wrote for the New Republic and supported Roosevelt for his first election, then was appalled at what Roosevelt actually did after reversing his campaign rhetoric. Flynn's honesty and devastating expose's of the Roosevelt Administration made him a prime target, to the point where Roosevelt directly pressure publishers to try and shut him up. You won't find the pandering to supposed "good intentions" in Flynn.

      Flynn also became head of America First opposing American entry into WWII up to Pearl Harbor, and Roosevelt was stealthily trying to get the country into the war despite its unpopularity, but The Roosevelt Myth does not deal with foreign policy.

      But Roosevelt was not worse than the Obama. Obama is the first president to hate the country. He has embraced and exploited Roosevelt's statism to take it to new levels of anti-American depravity and destruction on principle. But despite his deviousness, Obama is a symptom of what the population is now willing to tolerate and endorse. Flynn, Schlaes and a few others are devastating against Roosevelt, but despite all we already know, The Obama Myth has yet to be written.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by PURB 10 years ago
      Flynn's Roosevelt Myth was reviewed most favorably by Barbara Branden in TON (Dec, 1962) without the usual penultimate paragraph pointing out the book's flaws, which characterized most reviews. I've noticed renewed interest in this title.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by 10 years ago
      Hello straightlinelogic,
      Thank you for the suggestions. I knew the baloney we were fed in history class (public grade school) was hype. I have read several unflattering accounts as asides in other books, but I have not read any of the suggestions you have made. I did read The Politically Incorrect Guide to The Great Depression about five years ago and it just reinforced my understanding. That is a good series. I also found the one on The Founding Fathers a great short read.

      I can remember when my Grandparents were still living, telling me they thought he was great at the time, but later had reservations. Their only input at the time was the radio and they were seriously struggling during the depression and did not understand the causes... Live and learn, I guess. At least for some of us. :)

      I have copied your list to my own "books to look for" list.
      Thank you for the kind words and encouragement. :)

      By the way, I heard you online a week or so ago on a book interview show. Bravo!
      Looking forward to your next offering.
      Regards,
      O.A.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Ben_C 10 years ago
    My dad is a child of the depression. When asked, "dad, how did you survive the depression?" his response is: "our family banded togther and we took care of each other." Liberalism has destroyed the family unit and I don't see any real hope in the near future for its re establishment. My daughter aked me the difference between republicans and democrats. My response: republicans believe in personal responsibility, democrats in government dependence. Until the later changes history will repeat itself.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by 10 years ago
      Hello Ben_C,
      I quite agree. The destruction of the family unit and its support is a very significant factor contributing to the breakdown of our society... Very troubling and the impetus is clear.
      Regards,
      O.A.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by dbhalling 10 years ago
    For a shorter harder hitting book try FDR's Follies. I found Ms. Shlaes book a little long and rambly. But I have enjoyed her articles.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by 10 years ago
      Thank's dbh,
      I too found her a bit rambling, but I appreciate the need to be thorough and well researched in the face of what would surely be a firestorm of criticism form the progressives.
      As for an enjoyable read.... well, I prefer material that gets to the point a little faster too. :)
      Regards,
      O.A.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by IndianaGary 10 years ago
    While I have read quite a bit about the depression and FDR's exacerbation thereof, I think that you should read Judge Nap's "Theodore and Woodrow" to get a better sense of how progressivism and statism got a foothold in this country; FDR just pounded more nails into the countries coffin. His intellectual heir, Barack Obama is still pounding.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by wiggys 10 years ago
    I just happened to have read a review of a book "the roosevelt myth" by John T Flynn. the review was by Barbara Branden and it was published in the objectivist newsletter in the early 1960's, no date is shown. roosevelt has been reincarnated by 0. at the time of his election the country had 11 million unemploted, over sixteen million on reliefand a government debt of sixteen billion bucks.by 1939 he borrowed and spent seventeen billion, public money that is. over 11 million unemployed and over 19 million on relief. these are the tip of the iceburg of what his new deal did to the country. he didn't die soon enough. do you see any similarity to all who have followed him?
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by richrobinson 10 years ago
    Looks like a good one OA. thanks. I remember reading years ago that John W Davis who was the Democratic candidate for President in 1924 argued against many of the new Deal policies before the Supreme court. He is the last conservative type candidate to run as a Democrat.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by 10 years ago
      Wow! Davis was implicated by retired Marine Corps Major General Smedley Butler in the Business Plot, an alleged political conspiracy in 1933 to overthrow United States President Franklin D. Roosevelt... He was not charged though because it was hearsay.
      Quite a character...
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by richrobinson 10 years ago
        As I remember he was considered a man of great character. I need to search more about his Supreme Court challenges to the New Deal. A quick search showed little which doesn't surprise me.
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by Ben_C 10 years ago
    Thank you for the post. I bought the book and enjoy each page. Some of the people I know something about - many are new players. This book will be required reading for my daughter.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by bassboat 10 years ago
    I've read the Fogotten Man several times. It's an excellent book. I, like many people, grew up being told that FDR was responsible for getting us out of the Great Depression. Looking back it's easy to see how the press manipulates the people. If we need regulation then let's start with the press. The more I think about it the better of an idea it is. FDR was much worse than Carter. He was a little rich boy who toyed with people's lives. He emulated his cousin Teddy who was responsible for the ludicrous anti trust laws that stifle innovation and cost us more money instead. Kinda ironic that we pay more. It was another case of cronyism where connected people could get their way with a wink and a nod along with a sack of money. This is another example of the need for term limits. Read the book, you'll love it.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo