Is There a Cure for the Western Public Health Catastrophe?

Posted by freedomforall 11 months, 3 weeks ago to Science
17 comments | Share | Flag

Excerpt:
"What is perhaps surprising, but very important if one cares about optimising health spending, is how almost completely unimportant all the expensive stuff is for health. Major hospital operations, ICUs, designer medicines and so on basically do not move the dial, for three big reasons that medics often do not like to talk about.

The first is that hospitals are unhealthy places where visitors run major risks of getting sicker rather than getting better. The WHO, when it was still being useful, advertised studies that estimated that some 15 percent of people going to hospital pick up a nasty bug there, because after all it is where seriously sick people (including those sick with nasty bugs) go. That is a high risk that is practically never mentioned in the cost-benefit studies pharmaceutical companies churn out when marketing their latest wares.

Second, lots of expensive medicines and operations are given to people who are very close to death and have multiple other ailments, so preventing them from dying of one thing often just postpones death by a few weeks. The upshot is that the end of life is made lonelier, more painful and more stressful, but extremely profitable to both the hospital and Big Pharma.

Again, this is practically always downplayed in commercial health studies via a few useful tricks, like insisting that both treatment and placebo group have no other ailment than the one being studied and are thus much healthier than is true in practice.

Another trick is to compare an expensive new drug with an expensive old drug, and both only on fairly healthy populations rather than the sick ones who are more frequent drug recipients in practice. Much of the health system profits from the fear of death, with in-built massive exaggeration of benefits and underestimation of costs in the medical studies that routinely pop up in the Big Pharma advertising magazines (like the Lancet, the British Medical Journal, and so on).

A third reason why expensive interventions don’t move the dial much is that many of the medicines and operations pushed by Pharma and medics don’t actually work. For example, only 50% of drugs that get preliminary access to the US markets (after passing Phase II of that process) make it to full access (Phase III), with even fewer getting full approval, though they still make money for their manufacturers and distributors while being in ‘pending’ purgatory.

Also, tellingly, the large literature on ‘supply-induced demand’ (a booming line of research in the 1990s that has become a trickle in the top journals over the last 10 years) includes studies in which members of a doctor’s family were found to have received fewer operations on average than non-family individuals advised by the same doctor.

By implication, both the industry and the doctors themselves know that the benefits of their expensive interventions are exaggerated."
----------------------------------------------
Bottom line: Big Pharma (and their corrupt government conspirators) are lying, cheating, murdering scum.
Never do what they say to do and you'll live longer.
SOURCE URL: https://brownstone.org/articles/is-there-a-cure-for-the-western-public-health-catastrophe/


Add Comment

FORMATTING HELP

All Comments Hide marked as read Mark all as read

  • Posted by 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    Solution per the article:
    "we advocate closing down about 80 percent of the health sector, leaving only the most useful bits. A grandfathering period of a few years to complete the close-down, in which no new ‘health’ organisations can enter the market, would prevent a quick reentry of the same villains. The presumption of low efficacy of any new medicine or intervention should also help to prevent new tragedies akin to the opioid crisis, or other health emergencies directly caused by fancy drugs.

    The notion of what public health is about should also change. Clean water, cooking on electricity or gas, low air-polluting industries, efficient garbage collection, underground sewage, and encouragement towards healthy dietary habits and participation in sport should all be considered core public health investments. With the vast amount of money freed up by abolishing the useless bits of their present health spending, the US and other Western governments can easily afford large upgrades in these areas."
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by Lucky 11 months, 3 weeks ago
      Yes. A good article. It shows how back in the last C and the 19th.C great advances were made by a few elementary measures. This is where gov should concentrate (if anywhere).

      Studies. the docs own family have fewer interventions than others..
      Yes but they are healthier, yes but why/how are they healthier? That is the question to be set, not just providing more of the usual.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by CaptainKirk 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    Two Facts:
    1) Our Trauma Care is AMAZING!
    2) Our Lifestyle Care is the problem!

    This has led me (a Randian) to propose MAYBE we actually give free Trauma Care and only charge and insure against lifestyle diseases. Without government assisting the expense.

    Without the need to be insured for the risk of the #1 cause of bankruptcy (medical expenses), I would NOT carry health insurance. And most young people could opt out.

    Once that money is removed. You get this SPIKEY pricing whereby OBESE people will have to pay A LOT MORE for "health care" because their factors are largely lifestyle. But they will finally get the care they NEED... Not the one that keeps them sick longer.

    But when you watch this short video from a Rogan Episode. From someone INSIDE the industry explain how WE are getting screwed by the system being setup this way...
    It becomes even more clear what is wrong...

    Perverse Incentives!
    PS: I also believe that there should be a 100 year moratorium on working at the FDA, et al, and then going to work for a drug company! Including Family Members!

    https://youtu.be/nloxR3XpgaE?si=mOpah...
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ Abaco 11 months, 3 weeks ago
      "It is a profit-driven system, not a patient outcome-driven system."

      Bingo. Don't ever forget that. I'm late 50s and am not on any prescriptions. None. I workout 4+ times per week. Eat a good salad just about daily (don't eat them when traveling, for example...not safe). I have lost many friends due to prescribed pharmaceuticals.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
      • Posted by CaptainKirk 11 months, 3 weeks ago
        Same Age. Same thoughts.
        Although I went carnivore and gave up even the salads. I stopped eating out, etc.

        Zero Rx Drugs (unless I am treating something that REQUIRES it).

        Zero REGULAR Rx (never will I do a lifetime Rx).

        neighbor's mom was on 17 Rx drugs when she died. What a racket!
        Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
        • Posted by 11 months, 3 weeks ago
          Enjoy your 50's while you can. I noticed a change in my body a couple days before my 60th birthday and I was eating right and exercising wisely. It's been very slightly downhill since then, but I'm still a lot better off than almost everyone I know at my age.
          (Thanks to my nutritionist best friend. )
          What a racket 'health' has become.
          Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
          • Posted by CaptainKirk 11 months, 3 weeks ago
            FFA, yeah... I finally understand this comment:

            Youth is Wasted on the Young!

            LOL. We should start out OLD, live that way for a couple of years. Then be born into a crisp new body! MAYBE THEN we would realize:

            Our Bodies are the ONLY place we get to live!

            if you can stay off of the meds, and mostly outside of their system... I think life is better. My grandparents didn't have health insurance. Certainly my great grand parents never had it. And never needed it.

            But I appreciate the reminder. Us "youngsters" need to listen to those ahead of us. There is a LOT of pain and suffering we can avoid...

            May you have many more great years ahead of you!
            Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ Abaco 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    Somewhere along the line we forgot that "healthcare" is a business. It's the most lucrative type of business I could have gotten involved in as an engineer. That said, the government-healthcare complex is 100% run by big pharma. Big pharma builds the university facilities, bribes the lawmakers, writes the laws, has been largely exempted from liability, and has literally gotten away with murder (based on CDC data). So...good luck "fixing" this system. First thing I advise anybody to do is to become an educated consumer of their goods. Otherwise, they'll kill you. And, FWIW one could argue that engineering has probably done at least as much as modern medicine to save lives, if not more. In total, since (last time I checked) the medical industry kills (this was pre-covid) close to a quarter of a million of people per year in the United State - engineering has done much better for the people than "medicine" has. Try living in a society without modern plumbing...
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ BobCat 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    I see two solutions. First, get the govt out of the health care industry. This includes CDC and NIH. Let doctors be doctors and hospitals be hospitals. More burdensome regulations and gov spending is not the answer. How many hundreds of billions has been wasted on HIPPA- and the information is never safe?
    Second, people must be responsible for their own health. Today, most people have turned the responsibility of their health to the institution of white coats. People expect Dr's and Rx-ers to make them well and keep them well. Most people today have no idea what a healthy life style means, let alone giving up their destructive habits.
    But in the US, the only way we know to solve any problem is to throw more money down the rabbit hole...$$$....
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by $ blarman 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    I'd like to propose one other major partner to this debacle: health care "insurance" which shunts the costs of poor decision-making from the patient to the public. All insurance should be private and individual, not offered through employers. It should be transferrable from one state to another and should be comprised of two parts: maintenance insurance and catastrophic insurance. Maintenance insurance covers the day-to-day things like maintenance medications (insulin et al), etc. and standard doctor visits while catastrophic insurance covers things like appendectomies, cancer treatments, etc.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by tutor-turtle 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    No worries. Cross over the Mexican border (if you can, Mexican authorities are a lot smarter than our bunch) stroll over the border with the other 35 million Crimaleins claim "Asylum" get your $2400/ month SS benefits, food, clothing, shelter, healthcare, phone, cash..
    Because if you are retired and on social Security like I am, the as swipes running (ruining) our gobermint they are plotting and planing to cut our benefits to fund the Crimaleins and all the wars and countries that hate us.
    So sit back, relax, find some marshmallows (or hotdogs) to toast over the burning embers of whats left of our Republic.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
  • Posted by STEVEDUNN46 11 months, 3 weeks ago
    Stay healthy by ignoring the food pyramid. Ignor all government recommendations. All are controlled by large corporation food processors. Ignore recommendations from AHA, AMA, ADA. Just eat meat and meat products.
    Reply | Mark as read | Best of... | Permalink  
    • Posted by $ Abaco 11 months, 3 weeks ago
      Yep. Research the 7-nations study that set the parameters on animal fats and heart disease. They cut out half of the data to show some correlation. I remember playing college football in the 80s and being told, "You don't need more protein." Nothing was further from the truth. Government has zero business being involved in healthcare in any way.
      Reply | Mark as read | Parent | Best of... | Permalink  

FORMATTING HELP

  • Comment hidden. Undo