- Hot
- New
- Categories...
- Producer's Lounge
- Producer's Vault
- The Gulch: Live! (New)
- Ask the Gulch!
- Going Galt
- Books
- Business
- Classifieds
- Culture
- Economics
- Education
- Entertainment
- Government
- History
- Humor
- Legislation
- Movies
- News
- Philosophy
- Pics
- Politics
- Science
- Technology
- Video
- The Gulch: Best of
- The Gulch: Bugs
- The Gulch: Feature Requests
- The Gulch: Featured Producers
- The Gulch: General
- The Gulch: Introductions
- The Gulch: Local
- The Gulch: Promotions
- Marketplace
- Members
- Store
- More...
Michael Shellenberger, and environmentalist, says it best: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZXUR...
I was sitting on a plane one day and got into a discussion with the gentleman next to me. At the time I was living in Montana, which has a great environment (theoretically) for wind power. The man happened to be a wind turbine technician who flew out to Montana regularly but was based in Missouri. So we got into a discussion about his job.
He gave me the numbers on a typical wind turbine. They cost about $250,000 and are predominantly manufactured in France and then shipped over to the US and trucked to their new station. With these costs in mind and the amount of power a typical turbine can generate, the payback time for a generator running 100% of the time is nearly 25 years. In reality, the wind is only sufficient to turn the turbine about 50-70% of the time (in a windy area). Oops. That pushes the payback time out significantly.
But the real problem, he said, was that they aren't engineered for the extreme temperatures involved in Montana (metallurgy, etc.). According to the very technician who worked on these turbines, the ones in Montana were only functional about 30% of the time they could have been operating. What that does is basically say that a wind turbine never pays for itself. Without government subsidies, they are a project which is DOA.
They have a large turbine operation in the North Sea, thanks to Merkel's push to replace fossil based energy with wind.
The predictable result so far is that Germans pay several times higher rates for power than we do.
Add to this the ROI on the cost of the turbines and it looks like quite an attractive alternative!
Yesterday a thermometer on the front of my home read 102 degrees in the shade.
Wondering if a late Alabama summer that's usually in the high nineties would mess up the functions of a French windmill.
Or how about Florida for that matter? The coastline is often breezy down there but never always.
Are you saying "sure they would" to my "wondering" if my Alabama and Florida that "would mess up the functions of a French windmill?"
France is a North Atlantic nation. Though France does encounter significant humidity, atmospheric saturation is a factor of humidity and temperature, ie. the higher the temperature, the more water vapor can remain suspended in the air ready to condense. The temperatures in Alabama are typically higher than in France, so items engineered for use in Alabama are going to have to accommodate this higher saturation level (water is typically a very bad lubricant but a great corrosion agent) as well as the higher temperatures (metals have individual coefficients of expansion and tolerances in precision engines are and must remain very tight). What they really should have (at a bare minimum) are turbines engineered for the specific atmospheric/weather conditions in which they will be operating, ie different turbines for France vs Alabama vs Montana.
Thanks for the extra data, too. Sometimes the humidity here can really be bad.
Not presently, thank goodness. The predicted high for today is a more normal 97.
It usually feels like Fall in Alabama around mid-October. Sometimes Halloween night can actually be chilly. Sometimes . . .
Some winters there is no snow at all.
During the Nineties my Birmingham area and above actually had a blizzard that buried entire cars in places. Never saw anything like it.
About three years later an even weirder ice storm trapped me at the prison I'm now retired from working at. In rotation, officers slept on thin inmate mattresses and slightly thicker pillows on the floor in the visitation area or otherwise worked. The prison was locked down due to two-thirds of a single shift on their feet while the rest slept.
Heard on the car radio that cool air will move in wuithin a couple of days, dropping tempos into the eighties. I'm pretty sure that will be temporary, though. Been there, done that.
What they understand is "community organizer", "racist", "free stuff", "climate change" (according to them not in reality) and anything that falls into communist terminology.