Calculator Stories
ok, I have one for ya... an engineering friend was on his way to work. In the middle of the road, he noticed a calculator case. typical TI scientific calculator size (mid 80s). He stops, picks it up. Hoping to find a calculator. Instead it is perfectly stuffed with 10k in small bills. He sweats all day at work and comes home to an engineer and a working waitress english major. the bills are pulled and and counted. the word "shit" is flown around like no one has ever heard.....I am not telling the rest of the story. but...what's your calculator story?
The first, major, problem, is that unless the person doing the programming is the one taking the test, they've demonstrated only the ability to run software and no understanding of the course material. So if they put the numbers in and get an answer that is 5 orders of magnitude off, they have no clue what went wrong, nor even that anything IS wrong. Entering numbers into a keyboard doesn't demonstrate a knowledge of the underlying concepts - so the test is invalidated.
The second argument is that using the programmability essentially amounts to turning the test into a "take home" test. If programming is part of the skill set, then no problem. If not, it amounts to an artificial advantage for those who may have knowledge unrelated to the course material. In effect, if you spent two hours programming your calculator, and everyone gets one hour to take the test, your pre-programming means you have a sizable time advantage.
In general, I believe that learning to do something "by hand" before permitting calculators (or hand computers) is the way to go. That way, when your calculations show that you need 5 million feet of lumber to build a set of shelves, you at least have a clue something might be wrong.
But "she who must not be named" K, wants me to tell the story of how a crow tried to steal my HP45?? calculator one summer on the way home from taking circuit theory I. I was walking down the beautiful tree lined streets of Manhattan KS (Home of the K-state Wildcats) deep in thought about Kirchhoff's Laws when a crow jumps in front of me maybe 15 feet and caws at me. I think it is just a stupid bird so I keep walking, but the crow becomes belligerent, not will to give its ground and flies at me. I turn my head and duck and my (relatively new) HP calculator falls on the cement sidewalk as I back away. I am stunned as the crow lands on the sidewalk and picks up the calculator by a loop in the case and tries to fly away. I can't afford to lose my calculator so I run at the bird waving my hands and shouting. The crow got the calculator 3-4 feet off the ground before I startled it. I picked up the calculator happy to find it still worked and determined to defend it from all birds, bitches, or other vermin.
Then again, it's a sign of the times when you're the only person in your office who has a desk calculator...
He had a heckuva time adjusting to use my pocket calculator :)
In 11th grade, many year ago, I had an instructor who conducted a class experiment. Half of the class was given calculators to work with and the rest was left to do the algebra on paper by hand ( I was without). Every single person without a calculator finished the 25 problems well before those who used calculators.
Not quite the caliber story as they rest of you but it was an opportunity to share a memory that stuck with me all these years.
Today, children graduating college (let alone high school) can't do simple addition/subtraction in their heads.
I always wondered what the Apollo 11 (or 13) astronauts would have done had that been the norm then. Well, we got the engineering wrong, you'll miss the moon (or earth) by a few thousand miles, and run out of air 2 days before your projected landing rather than have a 72 hour reserve, but you should be proud to know that, while our answers were wrong, we tried. Really really hard.
That was cute, thanks!!! "I can add!"
Some of them, failing the 6x9, will say, "I'll use a calculator." I say, "Not for MY horse you won't!"
If you calculate the horse to get 30 ml of reserpine when 3 ml is required, the incorrect dose may kill the horse. There is no antidote.
I want my horse's vet to have a good sense of the numbers in dosing meds, and that means relying on the brain in addition to calculators or computers.
I'm awfully tempted to start a "remedial math for geniuses" class. We'll learn casting out nines, hand-calculation of square roots, calculating areas of fields by walking "Roman paces" to gather distances. There is so much one can learn, and I know such a small amount!
grades in her vet school prep curriculum, she was
unqualified because she didn't have round heels. -- j
was just getting started. I have no recent data, but
the memory of her honest appraisal is still fresh. -- j
Of course if all you see is the "results" and are stonewalled when you ask to see the original [climate] data, unadjusted, you have a different variety of fake data.
There are other techniques I won't reveal here.
Detecting fake data requires that the person who made it missed fixing the data or did not know what should be fixed to make it have a real appearance. Global Warming Science has this practice down to an art form, or at least it seems so. If not for email fubar we may have never known just how rigged that data was.
WRT actually reading. I overstated, perhaps could say I looked at every page.
I have become a fan of correlation analyses to identify our businesses (my group manages nine) financial methods that are different. Try to find the "fat" overhead in a company that is playing "hide the pea" sometime. It is a lot harder than you think, but sum all the overheads, divide by revenue, and correlate several businesses, and voila, lazy-chubby pops right out like superheterodyne pulling noise out of the floor.
Here's mine.
Last week my son stopped by. He walked in the front door holding a calculator pinched between his thumb and pointer finger, and said "is somebody trying to melt this thing?" It was my husband's calculator. He said "oh shit. I forgot I put that out there." It's a solar calculator that wasn't working, or so I'm assuming anyway. We live in AZ ... And it's July. The birds didn't bother it.
Anyone know where I can get a couple of new metal curser frames for my K&E 4081-3 Log Log Duplex Decitrig Slide Rule for a reasonable price? They seem to have dissolved, or oxidized away.
Aren't there any old guys out there? (What girl would admit to being old)?
The pinnacle of calculator-dom is the HP-41C (Continuous memory, programmable). Accessries include a magnetic card reader and pre-programmed plug-in modules). HP-41s are INDESTRUCTIBLE, almost. The display on mine is turning black at the ends but it should last a few more decades.
RPN (Reverse Polish Notation!).
Enter a number and it automatically clears the registers. Enter another number, THEN select what you want to do with it (Add, subtract, multiply, divide, square, raise to a power and so on). Parentheses aren't needed, just keep on truckin'. The interim result is always shown until finally, you're all done.
Scads of storage registers can save anything you like, such as a list of cars and the MPG each delivers.
My HP-41 is not for sale. Where can I get a good deal on a spare?
BTW, I have sliderules. In fact, some years back, Keuffel and Esser advertised in an engineering magazine (Industrial Research maybe) that they had a crate in a warehouse. Send them an SASE or something and get a free slide rule. Since then, I picked up a couple at second-hand stores. I have a nice one in a leather case for your belt. I wear it at science fiction conventions and such. "It is the formal computing device of a Jedi physicist, an elegant tool from a simpler time, from before the dark times and the empire."
About 1982 or so, in response to the creation of a computer science department at our community college, my physics instructor said, "We had sliderules, but no one majored in them."
My saving grace was Cleveland Public Schools. I had ten semesters of math in four years (counting summer school). I was actually in Calculus One when I got kicked out as a discipline problem and went to another school. I could not get into their calculus class, so I took another semester of "senior math", with probability and stuff.
My wife and I both can outrace the cashier. Again in CPS, in junior high, for three semesters, we had six weeks of "mental math" learning to estimate, borrow, carry, etc., in our heads. I picked up a few more tricks from Feynman's stories. Also, oddly enough, it was computer programming that put the icing on the cake. It was an easy lesson that you can guess almost anything by taking half the correction three times.
For what it is worth, that Polish guy was later let go, thank goodness.
My date of birth is 7-7-34.
I've used it hundreds of times but only recently, someone pointed out that when those numbers are put into a calculator and the calculator is turned upside down, it spells hell. I'm not sure of the significance if there is any.
SHELLOIL
Know what I remember better, tho? The watches (IIRC mine were usually Timexes) that had the same red LEDs in it - moonlighted during High School, and working at night they always just *worked*. They ate batteries like no ones business, tho - I got *very* adept at popping the back cover and sliding a new mercury cell in its place.
When the last one finally died I went through holy heck to find another. Never could... tho recently I saw one in an antique store. Felt really old then.
Oh... er... that was a MUCH OLDER friend who that happened to... I couldn't be that old... no way, no how...
Know what I remember from high school? Algebra teacher telling us "Sure, calculators are nifty (does anyone still use "nifty"??!!) but your slide role won't run out of batteries at the worst possible time". Never forgot it.
Of course, I envied the magnifying cursor on my friends, oh, what was that ugly yellow thing... Way fun (and easy) to use, but gads, how I hated that yellow color! Ick!!! I think it was a Pickett... Bleah.
I saw my old TI-33 in a box I was rummaging through the other day. I've got a number old calculators from the 70s and 80s.
Of course, I can remember calculators that weighed more (and were noisier) than modern desktop computers (cost more, too...)
For a period, when he was younger, my dad used to sell Freidens, Merchants, Monroes... a job he really loved, and one that caused Dr. Van Allen (of the radiation belts) to think he was a genius. :)
Now I use an HP33s. When they cancelled the HP32s and replaced with with the HP33s, the price of used HP32s shot up. I think I sold it for more than I paid for it and got the new HP33s.
I have an HP48gx that I never cared for. That tiny bit of latency when you do an operation drives me crazy.
The winter holidays for me are the Solstice, Christmas, and all the other ones that get shoehorned in around that time of year. We only celebrate the Solstice and Christmas.
I agree with your attitude on Excel.
I have to use it all the time, but I don't care for it. Or any of the MS-Office apps for that matter. Unfortunately that is what most of the work world uses. So of course your output has to be readable for that suite or be a pdf.
MS-Office has always been "adequate" for work but not a single one of the components has ever been best in class. Good enough, but not great.
I still spot check excel sheet with my HP calc as well. And installed some HP calc emulators on my ipad for nostalgia's sake as well as usability.
Brain;; it cost $135 and I had to drive to Memphis
to buy it. I used it for years, and even carried it
for a spare to my PE test. 3 slide rules, 3 calculators,
and spare batteries. a suitcase full of books. pens
and pencils and scaled rulers and everything but
a pocket protector.
the Bowmar was forwarded to a high school kid
and lasted 10 years.
today I use an hp 41cx which I bought for my first
wife when she tried computer science in '82.
tough machine. it winked out once (N batteries)
when I was negotiating the purchase of 20 acres
of land, and the "opposition" brought out a light-
powered thing which came in a cracker jack box
to finish up. embarrassed??? -- j
http://www.computerhistory.org/collectio...
http://www.amazon.com/HP-41CX/dp/B004BNR...
Yet the guy could multiply two, 3-digit numbers as fast, and in some cases faster, than I could enter them on a calculator...
For decades I thought RPN was just an ethnic joke. Then, I found my old manual for the calculator in an old box of books and, looking through it, found out that it was indeed the name. LOL.
My favorite story was actually told to me by my roommate at Cal Poly when we were in school there. It was during finals week when my buddy was walking through the 1st floor of the Achitecture building when, suddenly, a door from a classroom flew open near the end of a test (obviously) and a student dashed out. He made a beeline straight for a big trash can where he held out his calculator over the can and, gripping it at each end with his hands, he twisted it into a thousand pieces - explosively. I think he even yelled out, "Yeaahhh!!!" in anger while doing it.
I'll never forget that story.
I have my old 15c from college, one of the original 48 from my early engineering days, a couple 33s (for the P.E. exam) and now a 12c for my financial calcs. Great calculators. The old ones never die.
As a former Marine I think Annapolis and one of my best friends went to AF academy.
Figured the "College" in quotes and the engineering emphasis meant a service academy.
Of course had I put up Hudson High you would have been more offended :)
I also call it South Hudson Institute of Technology (Good ol' SHIT). It was a great school to be a grad from - emphasis on FROM. But that's part of the point. Over 4 yrs we lost 32%, far more than the fly-boys or squids.
I actually tried to get into AFA but with hay fever, couldn't pass the flight physical. I went to their SERE school during one summer training and have a family friend's daughter who just graduated this past May. Glad that I didn't get in. I much prefer Hudson High - more tradition, history, discipline, and even architecture.
AF didn't exist until the key west accords.
At that point they became independent and had to start their own traditions. All the Army traditions became part of the "competition". And therefore, never to be mentioned LOL
BTW, this calculator will do symbolic differentiation and integration as well as matrix math. In graduate digital controls class I flew though problems by pushing "x^-1", rather than doing the long-hand adjoint/determinant. Great calculator for 1987!
About 3yrs ago, I stopped carrying my HP48G (which was a waste on a management-puke like me anyway), and just use a nice RPN app on my iPhone and iPad!
Of course, that would be expecting the teacher to be somewhat expert in knowing the subject - or have enough common sense to figure it out.
Went against the wrong post...
Load more comments...